BF IDE

In this section we introduce the method of undetermined coefficients to find particular solutions to nonhomogeneous differential equation. We work a wide variety of examples illustrating the many guidelines for making the initial guess of the form of the particular solution that is needed for the method. BF IDE is the most complete BF developer tool available for OSX. Complete BF-O./.-C surface-mounted slim distribution board, white RAL 9016, 24 space units per row, 5 rows, height 900mm, width 543 mm, depth 140 mm, including door, front plates, DIN-rail mounting frame and neutral/PE terminals.

Note that brainfuck is typically lowercased except, often, at the start of a sentence.

Brainfuck is one of the most famous esoteric programming languages, and has inspired the creation of a host of other languages. Due to the fact that the last half of its name is often considered one of the most offensive words in the English language, it is sometimes referred to as 'brainf***', 'brainf*ck', 'brainfsck', 'b****fuck' (as a joke), 'brainf**k', 'branflakes', 'brainoof', 'brainfrick', 'bf', etc. This can make it a bit difficult to search for information regarding brainfuck on the web, as the proper name might not be used at all in some articles.

Language overview

Brainfuck operates on an array of memory cells, each initially set to zero. (In the original implementation, the array was 30,000 cells long, but this may not be part of the language specification; different sizes for the array length and cell size give different variants of the language). There is a pointer, initially pointing to the first memory cell. The commands are:

All characters other than ><+-.,[] should be considered comments and ignored. But, see extensions below.

History

Brainfuck was invented by Urban Müller in 1993, in an attempt to make a language for which he could write the smallest possible compiler for the Amiga OS, version 2.0. He managed to write a 240-byte compiler. The language was inspired by FALSE, which had a 1024-byte compiler. Müller chose to name the language brainfuck (with the initial letter in lower case, although it is now often capitalised).

It is not known to what extent Müller was aware of or influenced by Böhm's language P' published in 1964, of which brainfuck can be considered a minor variation.

Examples

Hello, World!

This program prints out the words Hello World!:

1 ++++++++Set Cell #0 to 8
2 [
3 >++++Add 4 to Cell #1; this will always set Cell #1 to 4
4 [as the cell will be cleared by the loop
5 >++Add 4*2 to Cell #2
6 >+++Add 4*3 to Cell #3
7 >+++Add 4*3 to Cell #4
8 >+Add 4 to Cell #5
9 <<<<-Decrement the loop counter in Cell #1
10 ]Loop till Cell #1 is zero
11 >+Add 1 to Cell #2
12 >+Add 1 to Cell #3
13 >-Subtract 1 from Cell #4
14 >>+Add 1 to Cell #6
15 [<]Move back to the first zero cell you find; this will
16 be Cell #1 which was cleared by the previous loop
17 <-Decrement the loop Counter in Cell #0
18 ]Loop till Cell #0 is zero
19
20 The result of this is:
21 Cell No : 0 1 2 3 4 5 6
22 Contents: 0 0 72 104 88 32 8
23 Pointer : ^
24
25 >>.Cell #2 has value 72 which is 'H'
26 >---.Subtract 3 from Cell #3 to get 101 which is 'e'
27 +++++++.+++.Likewise for 'llo' from Cell #3
28 >>.Cell #5 is 32 for the space
29 <-.Subtract 1 from Cell #4 for 87 to give a 'W'
30 <.Cell #3 was set to 'o' from the end of 'Hello'
31 +++.------.--------.Cell #3 for 'rl' and 'd'
32 >>+.Add 1 to Cell #5 gives us an exclamation point
33 >++.And finally a newline from Cell #6

The same program in minimised form:

This is a slightly more complex variant that often triggers interpreter bugs. This uses cell values below zero and so doesn't work on fascist, score-computing interpreters.

Short program printing Hello, World! by primo from http://codegolf.stackexchange.com/a/68494/6691. This program needs four cells to the left of the starting point (so standard scoring would give it an adjustment of four instructions and four ticks) and requires wrapping byte sized cells.

Currently, the shortest known program printing Hello, World! is written by KSab from https://codegolf.stackexchange.com/a/163590/59487:

Move value

This code piece moves the value of the current cell (cell0) two cells to the right (cell2):

With indentation and comments the same code looks like this:

Cat

A cat program writes its input directly to its output. As there is not a standard way to handle EOF in brainfuck, there are four versions of the program below, labelled by how they match common implementations of the interpreter. (see Implementation issues). Drivers enhanced vision.

EOF returns 0:

EOF returns -1:

No change on EOF, or EOF returns 0:

No change on EOF, or EOF returns -1:

Cell Size

This program outputs the cell width of the interpreter:

Bf Ideas

Libraries

• BrainF.Net is a .NET wrapper by Erwijet for executing brainfuck code.

Self-interpreters

Writing a self-interpreter in brainfuck is not a simple task, yet, several self-interpreters have been written throughout the years.

• by Frans Faase - Perhaps the first one.
• by Keymaker - Designed in the strictest 8-bit, non-wrapping, EOF = no change (EOF 0 works too) environment. The program emulates unbound cell size for cells (the program +[+] is valid and never ends) -- not really a brainfuck feature but it's there anyway -- and of course all the brainfuck programs written for the 8-bit non-wrapping environment work as supposed to. Supports infinite/unbound number of cells and nested loops.
• by Daniel B Cristofani - The shortest; see also dbfi
• by Clive Gifford - The fastest
• by Adam Domurad - Interprets Brainfuck code from the input until a %, then reads remaining input as input for the interpreted program. Comments are allowed, and up to 256-depth nested loops

Computational class

When the array is unbounded, or when the array is at least three cells long and can store unbounded values, brainfuck is Turing-complete, meaning that it is in the same computational class as universal Turing machines. This, plus its dearth of commands, makes it a canonical example of a Turing tarpit.

This can be shown in a number of ways and with various restrictions on the brainfuck program and/or interpreter. The following formulations require the array to be unbounded, but allow the value in each cell to be bounded:

• Daniel B Cristofani's implementation of a universal Turing machine in brainfuck provides a proof by simulation.
• Fairly trivial reductions can also be drawn between brainfuck and P', which has been formally shown to be Turing-complete.
• User:Keymakerhas shown that brainfuck is Turing-complete even if you can only adjust cells by incrementing 0s to 1s.
  • Ørjan Johansenhas added the further restriction that loops can only be nested two levels deep.

Cheap Homemade Teen Bf Ideas

Other formulations allow the array to be bounded, but require that the value in each cell be unbounded:

• Frans Faase gives a procedure for translating 5-register Universal Register Machines into brainfuck programs using five cells [1].
• Ørjan Johansen has made a conversion from iterated Collatz functions to 3-cell brainfuck (see that page for details).
• User:ais523has proved that The Waterfall Model can be transformed into brainfuck with only three pairs of loop brackets in the whole program. The number of cells needed to make this Turing-complete is theoretically bounded (based on the number of waterclocks needed for TWM), but is not precisely known.
  • Ørjan Johansen improved this construction to use only two pairs of loop brackets in the whole program. User:ais523 implemented the resulting construction, giving a compiler from The Waterfall Model (without output, and with only one halt counter) to two-loop brainfuck. The algorithm used always uses less than 48n² cells (where n is the number of counters), and less than 24n² cells if the number of counters is 1 less than half a prime number.

And still others require both the array and the value in each cell to be unbounded:

• Frans Faase gives a procedure for transforming Turing machines into brainfuck programs which constitutes a proof by translation.

Implementation issues

Brainfuck leaves a lot of things up to the implementation to decide, such as array and cell size, and what happens when EOF is read.

Memory and wrapping

The size of the cells and the cell array varies a lot in different implementations. A usual implementation will have either 8bit or 32bit cells with 30000 cells (in the positive direction). For Turing completeness either the number of cells must be unbounded or (at least) three unbounded cells are required, the former is usually assumed.

Urban Müller's compiler used an array of 30000 cells 8bit cells, while the interpreter only allowed 100 (of 5000) to be used. As the compiler was written in assembler there is no indication as to whether the cells are to be assumed to be signed or unsigned and the overflow semantics are of the usual twos complement (or unsigned byte) wrapping form. The interpreter uses signed 8bit characters (-128 to 127 range).

Other interpreters normally use a similar layout, however, some allow cells to the left of the start position or use different allowed ranges of cell values. Some limit the cells to only positive values or other reduced ranges, others allow a larger range including 'floating point' (which would usually be in effect a 53bit integer without wrapping) or even completely unbounded integers.

Note, that it's not possible for a brainfuck program to determine if its integers are officially signed or unsigned unless they are also non-wrapping. If the cells don't wrap then the loops [-] and [+] used after an number in the opposite direction will cause a crash (ie: an exception or a hang). Most optimisers will therefore assume these sequences set a zero even with unbounded integers.

Even with wrapping cells code can be written that depends on the cell size for example Brainfuck bitwidth conversions or the code below (which only works correctly with 8bits).

Newlines

The vast majority of brainfuck programs, following Urban Müller's original example programs, use 10 as newline on both input and output; this is also the convention used by Unix-based operating systems, including Linux and Mac OS X. Some other operating systems use different conventions for newline, and may use different conventions on input and on output, and different conventions in different programming environments (e.g. C versus assembly language). Several solutions to the problem are possible:

• Write brainfuck programs to accept multiple linefeed conventions. (Possible, though clunky, on input; not generally possible on output.)
• Write many versions of each brainfuck program, one for each programming environment. (Possible, but very unpleasant.)
• Forget portability and write programs for whatever implementation you are using. (A fairly common approach. May make it hard to share programs if your interpreter doesn't use 10 as newline.)
• Write brainfuck interpreters and compilers to translate newline to 10 on input, and 10 to newline on output, in environments where that is not already the case. (Easy and helpful, but often overlooked. Also, may break the few brainfuck programs that do binary i/o; so newline translation should ideally be able to be turned off with a switch.)
• Instead of having the user hit the 'Enter' key, expect the user to do something else to give a 10 to the interpreter; e.g., the user can feed the input from a file which uses 10s to end the lines, rather than from the keyboard. Send the output to a file too. (Possible but clunky.)

A few implementations allow the input to be 'raw' and sometimes non-blocking. If the input is in 'raw' mode it is not line buffered and key presses are passed to the program immediately. Non-blocking means that if there isn't a character available either immediately or after a short delay (for example 1/10 of a second) the input command will return an EOF indication.

EOF

EOF is a controversial issue. Many implementations return 0, some return -1, and several notable brainfuck programmers suggest that on EOF the memory cell should be left as-is, without modification. In the original distribution the compiler left the cell unchanged, while the interpreter used the EOF from C which, strictly speaking, could be any negative integer, but which usually is -1 (which, in the case of byte-sized cells, ends up as 255).

Conventions

The following summarizes the common conventions for making a brainfuck interpreter or compiler. It can be seen as a general specification for brainfuck, commonly accepted amongst the brainfuck community as a minimal base.It attempts to solve implementation issues by standardizing them.

Memory

• Memory should normally consist of 8 bit cells, a very fast compiler may use 32bit or larger cells. Floating point cells are strongly discouraged as are cells that are not a power of two in size. 'Bignum' cells are allowed but should be an option.
• Memory should wrap on overflow and underflow. (This also includes the [-] function with 'bignum' cells).
• Negative memory addresses should NOT be assumed to exist, however, an interpreter may provide some. (An optimising interpreter may be forced to)
• Memory should consist of at least 30000 cells, some existing brainfuck programs do need more so this should be configurable or unbounded.

Newlines

The input should be 'line buffered' until the user enters a newline at which point the program receives the edited line.

• OS newlines should be converted to 10 for input.
• 10s should be converted to OS newlines for output.

Note that most programming platforms and programming languages already do this for you, which might make converting 10s to OS newlines redundant.

Character set

The original brainfuck interpreter used the native character set of the host, ISO8859-1. Most modern brainfuck interpreters do the same, so this means that many current implementations will used UTF-8 as the character set and have access to ANSI control sequences. The majority of brainfuck programs only use ASCII with newlines, but the few that use extended sets follow the UTF-8+Ansi pattern.

EOF

An interpreter should normally either return Zero or leave the cell unchanged on EOF.

The Zero option matches the brainfuck language in that the only conditional in brainfuck is a comparison with zero. Using this form, in theory, allows slightly shorter code. For eight bit cells the 'leave the cell untouched' matches the C/Unix read(2) system call in that the character memory will be left unchanged on EOF. For Unix the EOF (or error) condition is signalled by the return value, which is lost with BF. If the interpreter's cells are more than eight bits the 'unchanged cell' can safely handle binary data. If the cells are eight bit or the interpreter sets the cells to zero on EOF binary data cannot be handled.

For a brainfuck program this means that ASCII data+EOF should be read using a [-], construct (or similar). Binary input should, probably, be read using a construct of the form [-]-,. This requires that input bytes are in the range 0.255 when the cell size exceeds eight bits.

Note: It is strongly recommended that an interpreter be configurable to all three normal form of EOF (Zero, minus one and unchanged).

Extensions

Some implementations also recognize the following symbols as meaningful:

The debug command # comes from brainfuck's original interpreter, written by Urban Müller. Because brainfuck programs have only one input source, brainfuck interpreters written in brainfuck (or other languages without file I/O) require ! to be able to distinguish a program's code from the input it is intended to process.

As all characters other than ><+-.,[] should be considered comments and ignored it is normal for an interpreter to have a method of disabling these extensions if required. This disabling may be automatic for '!' based on such things as if there is currently an open loop and/or if the program is being read from the 'standard input'.

As these commands are non-standard some interpreters use different codes for these functions.

Probably the next most frequently implemented extension is a command to comment out the rest of the line, however, experienced brainfuck programmers generally consider this useless mostly due to the existence of the header comments technique.

Algorithms

See Brainfuck algorithms, Brainfuck constants.

Related languages

See also Brainfuck extensions.

In publishing the formal programming language P' in 1964, Corrado Böhm used six symbols precisely equivalent to the brainfuck commands +, -, <, >, [, and ], and provided an explicit program for each of the basic functions that together serve to compute any partial recursive function. (So in a very real sense, the first 'brainfuck' programs appear in Bohm's 1964 paper.) Drivers halliburton energy services.

Many people at various times have tried to extend brainfuck to make it easier to program in, but such efforts have been compared to trying to make a luxury car by gluing parts onto a skateboard. Other people have been interested in variations of the language for theoretical purposes, pedagogical applications, etc. The sheer proliferation of languages equivalent to and derived from brainfuck led Chris Pressey to dub it 'the twelve-bar blues of esolang'. Some of the more interesting variants:

• pbrain is a brainfuck extension that supports procedures.
• cbrain is a derivative of pbrain as implemented in pbrain.c, adding integers and operators.
• RUM stands for 'bRainfUck iMproved.' and adds procedures, strings and repetition.
• Toadskin is a brainfuck variant that supports procedures, but uses a stack instead of an array.
• Brainfork adds a Y command to fork the current thread.
• Fm edits a string on alphabet {0,1,..,m-1} (m >= 2).
• FRAK assemble instructions to brainfuck code.
• FukYorBrane and BF Joust pit two Brainfuck-like programs against each other, as in Core War (see Redcode).
• Smallfuck operates only on bits and has no input- or output-commands.
• Bitter one-bit memory cells, four commands, equivalent to Smallfuck under certain circumstances
• Spoon uses a Huffman coded set of instructions corresponding to Brainfuck's commands.
• BrainDuino BF port on Arduino HW platform (based on Atmel's ATMega). Extended by two special I/O operations and special overflow protection.
• Puzzlang turns every program into an exercise in patience and logic puzzle skills. The lone X operator becomes any of brainfuck's instructions, depending on the surrounding characters.
• Alarm Clock Radio throws away the instructions to decrement the memory pointer or memory value.
• Portal and Portal 2 allows code-level pointer manipulation and theoretically implements the Wang-B Machine.
• tbf is a language that can be compiled to Brainfuck. It includes variables, strings, macros and improved loops.
• Grin adds more efficient arithmetic functions to Brainfuck.
• tinyBF and its variant RISBF are brainfuck equivalents with only 4 opcodes.
• Mindscrew could be considered an extension of pbrain which adds a separate array for storing procedures.
• Grawlix adds stack operations, decimal I/O, another loop structure, functions, multiply/divide by two

Some other funny variants:

• Ook! works exactly like brainfuck, except the syntax is in Orangutan.
• Blub is the same for fish.
• Brainloller has the same commands as brainfuck, except they're read from a png image.
• COW is the bovine version of 'Ook!', except cows are slow to react so the loops are different.
• Pi obfuscates Brainfuck instructions in random errors in pi digits.

Some languages inspired by brainfuck, but with more major differences:

• Aura requires data to be stored in the code space.
• PATH and SNUSP attempt to combine brainfuck with Befunge.
• Wierd arose out of an earlier attempt to combine brainfuck with Befunge.

See also

• EsoInterpreters, featuring several brainfuck interpreters written in other esoteric languages
• BFBASIC, a Basic to brainfuck compiler
• asm2bf - the only true brainfuck assembler.
• C2BF, a partially implemented C to brainfuck compiler
• FBP, a high level language to brainfuck compiler
• Binary lambda calculus, featuring an 829 bit (under 104 bytes) Brainfuck interpreter
• BFO, the first known brainfuck to brainfuck optimizer and compressor
• Category:Brainfuck, a collection of brainfuck related articles on this wiki
• Category:Brainfuck derivatives, languages based on brainfuck
• Brainfuck minus -, showing that ordinary brainfuck without the '-' instruction and cell range of 0-1 (without cell-wrapping!) is still Turing-complete

External resources

• Urban Müller's talk about Brainfuck (video) at Tamedia TX 2017
• Brian Raiter's site contains a summary, an informal standards guide, and a couple of interesting programs.
• Frans Faase's site includes a proof that brainfuck is Turing-complete.
• some brainfuck fluff contains many interesting programs, a solid interpreter, and suggestions for programmers and implementors, among other things.
• The Brainfuck Archive has a large selection of programs, implementations and utilities.
• Brainfuck Golf is a contest with the goal of writing a shortest program to do a certain task; see golf.
• brain------------------------------------------------------fuck.com features some interesting brainfuck programs.
• Making executable BF programs contains information on how to make executable brainfuck programs.
• The Lost Kingdom(from the Wayback Machine; retrieved on 31 October 2011), an adventure game in 2 megabytes of BF code generated with BFBASIC.
  • The above converted to Javascript.
• Brainfuck CSS descrambler (with comments), from the Gallery of CSS Descramblers.
• Brainfuck in the Esoteric File Archive, including implementations, programs and utilities.
• Taking- and Finally Taking Over The World are games written by hand in brainfuck.
• Mutato is a mashup of Core War, brainfuck, and genetic algorithms.

Notable implementations

For a longer list, see brainfuck implementations.

• Original distribution by Urban Müller from the AmiNet archive. Includes interpreter and compiler for the Amiga. The interpreter can be compiled with gcc by removing line 43, which says chkabort();. The associated readme file might also have some historical interest.
• Also Written In Brainfuck (Awib) is an optimizing brainfuck compiler written in brainfuck, generates various conversions including i386 executable code for Linux.
• Esotope Brainfuck compiler is an optimizing Brainfuck-to-C compiler written in Python, with well optimised code.
• Brainfuck compiler/translator to COBOL or C.

Interpreters in plain C

• bffsree is a optimizing interpreter that claims to be fastest in class. (No source code)
• Optimizing BF interpreter is a very fast C interpreter, fastest in its class.
• yperBrainfuck a very fast JIT that is also a Interpreter written in C.

Interpreters in C++

• BrainForked is a fast non-JIT interpreter in C++.
• An interpreter written by Chinese users. It can visualize code, but unfortunately it can't handle undefined characters.

JIT Interpreters

• libbf is a very fast JIT interpreter, still very fast ten years later.
• Tritium is a optimizing interpreter that claims to be fastest in all classes. (including plain C)
• Wilfred bfc is a fast interpreter written in Rust using LLVM.

Hardware implementations

Bf Ideas

• The Brainf*ck CPU Project is a VHDL implementation of a brainfuck CPU

JavaScript interpreter